Please note that insecticidal soaps have "POTASSIUM salts of fatty acids"....Thus, if you want to make insecticidal soap from scratch, you need to use soaps like Murphy Oil Soap, Lysol Brand Cleaner Original Scent (Concentrate) which contain potassium hydroxide,
You only need to use a 1% dilution with any clean NON chlorinated water. NO chlorine!!
NOTE:
DO NOT use soaps that contain LYE!! (sodium hydroxide).
DO NOT use detergents such as liquid dish soap!!
Other products that contain potassium-hydroxide http://www.potassium-hydroxide.com/productcontaining.htm
Unlike soap which is organic, detergents are chemical cleaners and are toxic to most plants.
There are now major brand garden safe insecticidal soap that are very good to kill the aphids on contact. I think the best for killing aphids is lady bug larvae. I see these larvae making aphids on the run.
Store bought brands of insecticidal soap certainly costs more than homemade concoctions, but a little goes a long way and it's formulated to be hard on bugs and easy on plants. That's the primary problem with homemade solutions, they can strip the waxy coating right off plants resulting in damage.
There are animal and plant based formulations available.
Application
Spray Bottle or Garden Sprayer
The reason that soap kills insects effectively is the fatty acids from the animal fats the soap is made from which is why you need real soap and not a detergent. Those fatty acids dissolve the target insects exoskeleton so they dehydrate.
It is therefore important to spray the insecticide directly on pests, saturating them thoroughly. Spray every bit of the plant with the soap insecticide, paying special attention to intersections and the undersides of leaves where pests hide and lay eggs. Once the soap residue has dried on the plant, it will lose its insect-killing properties. Rinse off the film and reapply about once a week until no signs of infestation are visible. Soap insecticides only kill small, soft-bodied insects like aphids, spider mites, white flies, mealybugs, and immature scales. They will also destroy all eggs, including those of moths, flies, and beetles, as well as very small larvae. Larger pests (Japanese beetles, maggots, and caterpillars, for example) will be unaffected. For this reason, adding an all-purpose repellant to the mixture may be beneficial. Otherwise, you may have to resort to commercial products to eradicate these pests.
Do NOT use garlic as this may burn the leaves!! Garlic, however, will help keep deer and rabbit’s at bay.
Murphy's oil soap and Lysol are not good choices -- they both contain Potassium hydroxide instead use a product that only contains "POTASSIUM salts of fatty acids"
ReplyDeleteYou can buy commercial insecticidal soaps very inexpensively and you really don't need to use much - a little goes a long way.
SAFER brand makes good reasonably priced products.
I am an organic gardener FYI, aside from managing an earth friendly green cleaning service in New York city.
Cindy
www.greatgreencleaning.com
Cindy..
Deletewww.death2mites.com
While you are an organic gardener, you dont know anything about soap or making soap. We make all our own liquid soap to go into our product. What do you think Lye does? If its done correctly, the end solution will have zero lye in it. If you are doing cleaning and you have zero concept of what soap is, how do you get anything clean?
Who would hire anyone to clean if they dont comprehend the basic tool of cleaning... SOAP and SURFACTANTS!
Cindy may be an organic gardener, but she is totally wrong on the organic chemistry of soap.
ReplyDeleteAny liquid soap (not detergent) is made by the reaction or saponification of fatty acids and potassium hydroxide, a strong alkali. The makers of Murphy's soap make a big deal about using mostly all natural ingredients and their potassium hydroxide must be reacted with the oils or thee is no soap. This reaction of fatty acids and potassium hydroxide produces POTASSIUM SALTS OF FATTY ACIDS.
FYI, if you react fatty acids with sodium hydroxide another strong alkali you get solid soaps, like Ivory, Dial, etc.
Thank you for your reply. It is very helpful. :)
DeleteWill the dilution of 1% Murphy's and clear water be able to affect moss/ mildew/ algae as the Safer product does?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteYou WANT KOH! Murphy's or Bronner's ..just add an ounce Bronner's liquid soap per gallon of non-city water (no chlorine) and start shooting, must touch insect/egg/pest to ensure kill, dries basically inert, half-life of a day, can eat food next day after quick rinse, a little absolutely won't hurt you, not a carcinogen, but don't ingest it anyway
ReplyDeleteMurphy oil is extract
ReplyDelete